THE AUGURY · MSP MARKETING · 03

What Makes a Good MSP Backlink? Four Questions Before You Invest

Assess MSP backlink opportunities with four practical questions about buyer relevance, editorial choice and scale. Avoid wasting your MSP SEO budget on weak links.

THE LINK TEST tarot card artwork from Jackdaw for the post What Makes a Good Backlink? A Simple Test for MSP Marketing Decisions

MSP owners who spend months on a link-building campaign and see nothing move in search usually have the same problem. They chased links without a filter for whether a given link was worth chasing. Volume without judgment ends with a long list of sites nobody reads pointing at a page Google still won't rank.

A good backlink is one an editor gave you freely because your content helped their readers. It sits on a page people read, on a site your buyers or referral partners trust, and it would still be worth having if search engines didn't exist. Links you created yourself, paid for, traded for at scale, or manufactured fail that test, no matter what an SEO tool scores them.

In this post:

Google's original insight was simple: if many credible sources point to a page, that page is probably worth reading.

The system treated links like citations in academic publishing. A paper nobody cited probably wasn't moving the field forward. A paper every serious researcher cited was worth paying attention to. That logic held up for a long time, and in its core form, it still does.

Manufactured agreement is what breaks it. When links exist because someone paid for them, traded for them, or gamed them into existence, instead of because an editor decided they helped readers, the signal turns into noise. Google has spent two decades getting better at telling the difference.

For your MSP, the practical point is this. A link a real editor gave freely because your content helped their audience is worth something. A link you arranged, purchased, or swapped is worth very little, and chasing it takes time you could have spent building something that works.

"The MSPs I see chasing links are almost always chasing the wrong thing. A link is a voluntary vote of editorial confidence. The moment you arrange that vote — pay for it, trade for it, manufacture it — you've built something that looks like authority but isn't. That's a worse position than starting from zero, because at least zero is honest." Ian Richardson, Founder, Fox & Crow Group

Would an Industry Peer Cite This?

The cleanest way to judge link quality is to borrow the academic framing directly.

Say your MSP published a short guide on how small businesses in your city should evaluate IT providers before signing a managed services agreement. A local business journal links to it from its buyer's guide section. A chamber of commerce director shares it with members and lists it on the chamber's resource page. A commercial insurance broker who works with small businesses links to it from their blog, because their clients keep asking about technology risk.

None of those people asked you first. None of them got anything in exchange. They linked because the guide answered a question their own audience was asking.

That's a citation, and it's what Google is trying to measure.

Now say you paid a directory a monthly fee to list your MSP, traded links with another vendor, or paid a content farm to mention your site in a few posts a week. The HTML looks identical, but the signal behind it is completely different. Google's job is to tell the two apart, and it has gotten good at it.

Four questions do most of the work when you're sorting link opportunities.

If the only reason a link has value is the SEO credit it might pass, it probably won't pass much. Links worth earning tend to have referral value on their own. They sit where your target clients or referral partners already spend time.

Would a prospect feel differently about your MSP if they saw it?

A link from the regional business journal, a local university's vendor resource page, or a respected industry association changes how people see your business. A link from a directory that lists every MSP in North America doesn't. If you'd be proud to name the linking site in a meeting with a new prospect, you're probably looking at a real link.

Did the site's editor make a real choice?

The word "editorial" matters here. Someone who controls a publication or website decided, without being paid or pressured, that your content was worth pointing their readers toward. That decision is the signal. Payment, reciprocal agreements, and automated submissions all skip the decision, so they skip the signal too.

Good links are hard to earn, and that's how it should be. If a type of link can be produced quickly and cheaply at volume, it usually doesn't involve the editorial judgment that makes links valuable. One trusted local source can beat a hundred links on sites built to sell placements.

If you can answer yes to all four, pursue it. If you catch yourself arguing your way into a yes on any of them, stop.

You can't endorse yourself and have it count. Directory listings you fill out, social profiles that link back to your site, and forum comments with your URL in the signature don't carry editorial weight. They usually don't hurt you, but they aren't what you're trying to build.

Paid placements don't carry trust. Once money changes hands for a link, the editorial judgment that gave it value is gone. The site linked to you because you paid. Google's guidelines are explicit about this. Asking whether buying backlinks is safe comes down to asking whether a counterfeit trust signal will work. It won't.

One reciprocal link between two businesses with a real relationship, where each audience benefits from the other, is fine. A system for swapping links with anyone who'll agree is something else. The exchange is the point, and the reader is an afterthought. Do it once with a real partner. Don't build a process around it.

Scraping other sites' content and republishing it, spinning articles to create link targets, or building networks of fake sites to point at your MSP's domain is manipulation. These tactics have been ineffective for years and get less effective all the time. They also create duplicate content and other problems that are hard to recover from once they're discovered.

Vendors link to an MSP when the MSP has published something that makes the vendor look good by association: a case study, a technical guide, or a client success story that reflects well on the product or program.

Chambers and business associations link when an MSP has contributed something useful to the local business community. A workshop summary. A cybersecurity resource written for non-technical readers. A guide to evaluating technology vendors that a business owner would read.

Clients link when they're proud of the relationship and the content gives them a reason to share it.

None of those links happen because an MSP submitted a URL to a form. They happen because someone built something worth pointing to and put it in front of the right people. That's the work underneath any content marketing strategy for MSPs that earns links, and it's what turns a link into a trust signal.

What to Do Next

Make a list of every link opportunity currently on your plate: directory renewals, link packages a vendor pitched you, guest post offers, and the places you've been meaning to contribute.

Run each one through the four questions:

  • Would you want this link if search engines didn't exist?
  • Would a prospect feel differently about your MSP after seeing it?
  • Did an editor make a real choice to include it?
  • Could you get it at scale without the quality dropping?

Cross off anything that fails. For each one that passes, write down who decides whether you get the link and what they'd need to see from you. A vendor wants a case study. A chamber wants a plain-language resource for its members. A client wants a success story they're comfortable sharing.

Then build the first one.

If the only way to get a link involves a workaround, it's a risk you're taking on, and it won't build anything.

A Jackdaw reading shows how your site's SEO health and search visibility compare with your local MSP competitors, so you can see whether your link-building is closing the gap. Request a Reading

What makes a good backlink for an MSP is an editor's free choice to link to you because your content helped their readers. The best ones sit on pages people read, on sites your buyers or referral partners trust, such as a regional business journal, a chamber of commerce resource page, or an industry association your clients belong to.

An MSP can tell if a backlink is good or bad with two quick checks: you'd want the link even if search engines didn't exist, and you'd be comfortable naming the linking site to a prospect. If you have to build an argument for why it's a good link, it probably isn't.

Low-quality backlinks usually don't hurt an MSP's SEO directly, because search engines tend to ignore weak or manipulative links rather than penalize them. The bigger cost is the time and budget spent chasing them instead of building content worth citing.

Buying backlinks isn't a good bet for MSP SEO. Paid links aren't editorially earned, so they don't carry the trust signal search engines look for, and Google's guidelines treat them as link schemes. The return rarely justifies the spend, and that budget does more on content.

A natural backlink for an MSP is one given freely because the linking site's editor believed it added value for their own readers. Nobody paid for it, traded for it, or submitted it. The editor's independent judgment is what makes it count.

An MSP rarely needs to disavow bad backlinks, because most low-quality links are ignored rather than held against you. Disavowing is worth considering only if you know links were bought or built by a past vendor in a way that could look manipulative.