LAST UPDATED: JULY 2026
This lesson ends with a short workbook. Answer the prompts as you go. They save anonymously in your browser, no login or email needed. Since there's no account, the only durable copy is what you print or save yourself. Use the SAVE PROGRESS link in the nav above any time.
How to Hire an MSP Marketing Vendor
Hiring a marketing vendor is one of the most high-stakes decisions an MSP owner can make. Choose correctly, and you gain a powerful growth engine. Choose poorly, and you waste thousands of dollars and months of time, often ending up more frustrated than when you started.
The problem is that marketing vendors are professional communicators. They are very good at selling themselves, but their ability to market a marketing agency doesn't necessarily mean they can market a managed service provider. To find the right partner, you need to move past the sales pitch and look at the underlying mechanics of how they work.
Getting Started
Vertical Specialists vs. Generalist Agencies
The first choice you'll face is whether to hire an "MSP-specific" agency or a generalist marketing agency.
MSP Specialists already understand your business model. They know what a QBR is, the difference between MRR and project revenue, and the typical pain points of a small business owner worried about cybersecurity. The downside is that they often use the same templates for all their clients, making your marketing look like every other MSP's.
Generalist Agencies bring fresh ideas from other industries. They can help you stand out by applying tactics that your competitors aren't using. The downside is the "learning tax." You'll spend the first three months of the engagement teaching them what an MSP actually does.
Example: "Snake River Tech" in Idaho Falls interviewed both an MSP-specific agency and a generalist B2B agency. They chose the generalist because they wanted to stand out from the "blue-and-white shield" look of their local competitors. While the first month was slow due to the "learning tax," by month six they had the most unique-looking brand in their market.
TOOLS CAN HELP WITH THIS
Free vendor evaluation tools exist to help with this. Book a free call with us to see what we recommend for your MSP.
THE TELLTALE SIGN MOST OWNERS MISS
Before you ever get on a call, look at how the agency markets itself. Check their own website (is it current, fast, and well-written?), their social media accounts (are they actually posting, or is the feed stale?), and, if you can, their traffic and search visibility. An agency that can't find the time to run its own marketing is very likely understaffed. If they aren't taking care of their own pipeline, they don't have the bandwidth to give a first-time client, someone who needs the most hands-on help, the attention that engagement requires.
The Vetting Process: Questions to Ask
Don't just ask for a portfolio. Ask questions that reveal their process and their understanding of your business goals.
- "What is your experience with the MSP sales cycle?" If they expect leads to convert in 30 days, they don't understand the industry.
- "How do you measure success?" Look for vendors who talk about meetings and qualified opportunities, not just "impressions" or "clicks."
- "Who will actually be doing the work?" Often, the person who sells you the contract isn't the person managing your account. Ask to meet the account manager.
- "What do you need from me to be successful?" A good vendor will have clear requirements for owner involvement. Beware the vendor who says they "handle everything" without your input.
- "What's done by a human, and what's done by AI?" Ask this directly, especially for website builds. A vendor should be able to explain exactly where AI speeds up their process (first drafts, image generation, code scaffolding) versus where a human designer or developer does the real work: custom design decisions, security hardening, and QA. If they're vague, or if a "custom website" turns out to be an AI-generated template nobody reviewed, you'll end up with a site that looks like everyone else's and hasn't been checked for basic security holes.
FOR MSP OWNERS SPECIFICALLY
The "MSP Specialist" market is crowded with vendors who sell "marketing in a box." While these can be a good starting point for a very small MSP, they often lead to a "sea of sameness." If you're looking to truly differentiate your business, you need a vendor who is willing to do the work to find your unique voice, rather than just plugging your logo into a pre-written blog post about "The Top 5 Benefits of the Cloud."
Red Flags to Watch For
If you see any of these during the sales process, proceed with extreme caution:
- Guaranteed Rankings or Leads. No one can guarantee a specific number of leads or a #1 ranking on Google. Anyone who does is likely using "black hat" tactics that could hurt you in the long run.
- Proprietary Platforms. If they insist you build your website on their custom, closed-source CMS, you are being "locked in." If you ever want to leave, you'll have to rebuild from scratch.
- Lack of Transparency. You should have full access to your Google Analytics, your ad accounts, and your CRM data. If the vendor "owns" the accounts and only gives you reports, that's a major red flag.
- Long Lock-In Contracts. Be wary of any vendor who wants you to sign a 2-3 year commitment upfront. If their approach isn't showing results within the first 12 months, another 12-24 months of the same approach won't fix it, it'll just cost you more while you wait to find out. Look for month-to-month terms or a short initial term (90 days to a year) with an easy off-ramp.
Setting the Engagement Up for Success
Once you've chosen a vendor, the first 90 days are critical. Here is how to ensure a smooth onboarding:
- Define clear KPIs early. Agree on what success looks like in writing before the first campaign launches.
- Establish a communication rhythm. Set up a standing bi-weekly meeting and stick to it.
- Provide deep context. Share your existing client list, your most successful proposals, and your biggest "war stories." The more they know about your business, the better they can market it.
THIS IS NOT A "SET AND FORGET" PURCHASE
A marketing vendor is not a vending machine, it's more like hiring an employee. There is no easy button. If you skip the meetings, ignore the reports, and never push back when something isn't working, the engagement will quietly drift, and you'll have no one to blame but yourself. You have to show up, actively participate, course-correct when the data says something isn't working, and hold your vendor accountable to the KPIs you agreed on. In marketing, as in management, you get what you tolerate.
In the 102 lesson, we'll dive into the specifics of contract negotiation, managing multiple vendors, and knowing when it's time to fire a vendor.
Workbook: Try This Now
Scope your vendor search before you start shopping
If you're outsourcing any part of your marketing, this workbook turns 'find someone good' into a process — scope first, then vet on evidence, not the pitch.
0 of 6 answered